"We are All Writers Now" seems to defend forms of online writing like Facebook and Twitter against critics that claim these forms of writing are "sad testaments to our literary degradation." It makes excellent points to point out the usefulness of blogging, Facebook, and Twitter. The author states that nearly everyone uses these online tools to write, and if the best way to become a better writer is to practice, then who can argue that they are not useful at the minimum for that purpose? Additionally, they encourage users to find ways to write more concisely and with funnier and wittier prose. Here is where I would enter a supporting example link of my funny friend Blake, who always finds a way to make me at least chuckle via his status updates on MySpace. However, he cusses a lot and I think it would be quite inappropriate, unfortunately.
"Traditional Writing Skills Don't Work on the Web" argues, quite obviously, that writing in the traditional sense (like in an English essay), is "utterly useless" on the web. The common theme states that in traditional writing, we are taught to say what we are going to say, say what we say, then say what we said. This style, according to the author, has no use on the web due to the lack of attention span of web users. The author seems to be implying the the writer is trying to sell either his word, web page, or product of some sort. With this assumption in mind, it is easy to agree with him. People don't "Google" "used cars in the Flint Area" to find a site that tells them that they have used cars in the Flint Area. It's redundant and wordy and wastes the searcher's time. People (or people like me at least) are impatient and want to get to the meat of the search: the models, makers, prices, etc.
"Words for Print vs Words for Web" compares the benefits of writing on the web and printing in a magazine. There are things that printing can do, the author says, that to this day, the web cannot do for writing. As a person that is completely ignorant to the wonders of magazine development, I have to take the author's word for it that things print can do like "juxtapose text and image more concretely," are true. I have a hunch that as technology advances, a software application will be developed that will revolutionize magazine creation by utilizing and expanding the uses of magazine development, perhaps to the point that it will cause online magazines to be superior, at the least, in cost effectiveness to the printed magazine. Newspapers and magazines like The Flint Journal struggle for consumers, and the number of people that check online news sites grows. This situation calls for the development of a new avenue of commercialism for newspapers and magazines. I believe it's only a matter of time and technological advances.
Monday, September 14, 2009
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
For "Words for Print vs Words for Web" I agree with you that from particular persons point of view that does not know about magazine development has to believe the writers words to an extent. When reading the "Traditional Writing Skills don’t Work on the Web" I did not pick up on what you tied in with a Google search. Now I am remembering and it makes a little more sense now.
ReplyDeleteThis post provides a solid summary of the readings in addition to your own thoughts on the subjects addressed. I am curious, though, if online writing will forever change offline writing. I mean, a course like ours is but one of many options available to students (English majors and non-majors alike), but could all writing courses soon have an online foundation?
ReplyDeleteAlso, regarding your comments about "Words for Print vs. Words for Web," have you seen/heard about Google Fast Flip? http://fastflip.googlelabs.com/