Thursday, October 1, 2009

Who You Callin' a Plagiarizer?

Plagiarism is dishonest, plain and simple. Although I can understand why someone would plagiarize (numerous examples of whys are listed in "Defining and Avoiding Plagiarism"), I still completely disagree with its practice. The damage it can cause to the student and the credibility of the course and institution far outweighs the time it may save.
Students may plagiarize due to poor time management, on accident due to misuse of source citation, pressure to succeed coupled with lack of confidence, or just laziness. In my history as a student, I have witnessed and even participated in varying degrees of plagiarism. Throughout grade school, teachers taught us, unknowingly I assume, to plagiarize. They would have the students rearrange the sentences or use synonyms of the very words of the sources. When finished with these short steps, the work was complete: no citation needed. This, I am relatively certain, would still fall into the category of plagiarism.
The proper use of sources is to use them for research, develop original concepts on ideas based on those sources, and present them, citing the original work where its own ideas are presented. "Defining and Avoiding Plagiarism" puts a fair amount of responsibility on the faculty and administrators of colleges in properly encouraging the avoidance of plagiarism. It very accurately describes most students' novice abilities to research, draft, and cite sources. They need to be walked through these processes, especially in the entry level courses. Faculty must help the students understand the consequences of plagiarizing and the benefits of performing their own research and writing. As a teacher-to-be, this information was quite helpful. Students very much need to know the why as well as the how. It allows them to place personal value and realism into the concepts of work that are taught to them.
"The Ecstacy of Influence" speaks of works, not only writing, that influence others' work. It argues that all ideas have been influenced by preceding ideas. Walt Disney, for example, has struck gold on a number of stories that it did not create: "Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs, Fantasia, Pinocchio, Dumbo, Bambi, Song of the South, Cinderella, Alice in Wonderland, Robin Hood, Peter Pan, Lady and the Tramp, Mulan, Sleeping Beauty, The Sword in the Stone, The Jungle Book, and, alas, Treasure Planet." The hypocracy it exhibits by ensuing lawsuits against individuals that use characters from these stories in art is comical. This article seems to broaden the term plagiarism to all forms of work, not only writing. Examples other than writing that are listed include movies, songs, and anything else that can be copied and portrayed as original work.
Plagiarism reminds me of when I was a child, trying to win over a girl. I would take a form of poetry or song lyrics, and write them in a note to the girl as if I had written them myself. It worked great sometimes, but when I got caught, it was quite embarassing. It would have been better, in hindsight, to develop my own creative mind and avoid the risk of shame associated with being a fraud.

2 comments:

  1. What's important to keep in mind with these different examples is the context. If a kind of plagiarism is knowingly and willfully endorsed by a teacher, as in the writing example (as well as the assignment due next Tuesday), I'd like to think that others would be understanding of the situation. The end result, after all, isn't so much plagiarism as it is a writing exercise, right?

    ReplyDelete
  2. I love how you put your ideas in such a straightforward way: "plagiarism is dishonest, plain and simple." I couldn't have said it better myself. I agree with you that there are obviously reasons why students do it, more often than not because they didn't realize they were doing it, but that is why it is so important that guidelines be set. Also, faculty should make more of an effort to encourage students to present their own, original work, rather than giving out assignments that don't pique students' interests (emphasizing the positive rather than the negative.)

    ReplyDelete